Sudden Scare.
Recent sales
31 completed listings
10Neither PSA nor CGC has published a population report for this card, so the prices below are the best case rather than the likely one.
Why the verdict weights the odds
A PSA 10 sells for $199.99 against $0.10 ungraded plus $79.99 at Regular. Without a PSA population report there is nothing to weight those grades by, so the verdict beside the card speaks in best cases rather than averages. CGC numbers cannot stand in: the prices on this ladder are PSA prices and a CGC 10 is an easier grade to reach.
Card facts
- Card number
- 164/204
- Rarity
- Uncommon
- Set released
- Nov 7, 2025
- Printings priced
- 2
Whispers in the Well261 cards- Complete set value
- $6.5k
- 7 day move
- -0.2%
More from Whispers in the Well
All 261 cards →
$1,345–Ariel - Ethereal Voice (Iconic)241/204
$983.87–Hades - Looking for a Deal (Iconic)242/204
$790.13▼-0.2%Spooky Sight (Enchanted)237/204
$583.18–Cinderella - Dream Come True (Enchanted)236/204
$346.59–Can't Hold It Back Anymore (Enchanted)228/204
$264.27▲0.2%The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted)232/204What moves the price of this card
The Sudden Scare on this page is the Cold Foil printing from Whispers in the Well, and it trades at $0.48 in near mint condition. The other 1 printing of the same card sits lower, which is normal: the scarcer print run always carries the premium.
Graded, it runs PSA 10 $199.99. 31 completed sales are on file.
Condition does most of the work below the surface. A copy with soft corners or a print line off centre trades well under the market price shown here, and a copy clean enough to grade trades well above it, which is why the PSA 10 sits at $199.99. Before you value your own copy, look at the corners under a light and check the centring on the back, where most cards give themselves away.