LORCANAVALUES
Home / Whispers in the Well / The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted)
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) 232/204 from Whispers in the Well
Enchanted
Sold prices oneBay

The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted).

Whispers in the Well · 232/204 · Enchanted · Nov 7, 2025

Raw market value
$199.99.
TCGplayer market · near mint, ungraded
26 ungraded copies sold in 90 days, median $201.25
49 on record, $122.50 to $387.12
monthly median sold price
$100$320NOV '25FEB '26MAY '26AUG '26

81.4% of copies sent to PSA come back a 10. Sold and median are 90 days of completed eBay and TCGplayer listings. The 9.5 is a CGC and BGS grade, so it carries no PSA population.

Recent sales

71 completed listings
Grade
Where
Sort
SoldGradeListingPrice
Oct 13, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Whispers in the Well The Headless Horseman 232/204 232/204$149.99
Oct 11, 2026RaweBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL #232/204 HEADLESS HORSEMAN ENCHANTED 1/C1$157.92
Oct 10, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$199.37
Oct 1, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$214.95
Sep 30, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$198.89
Sep 19, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$209.99
Sep 17, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$198.01
Sep 10, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$800
Sep 8, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$200
Sep 7, 2026RaweBayRavensburger Lorcana Headless Horseman 232/204 Enchanted Foil EN 232/204$260
Sep 7, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana The Headless Horseman 232/204 Enchanted Whispers In The Well 232/204$250
Sep 7, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$209.70
Sep 3, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$199.25
Sep 2, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$199.25
Aug 30, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$187.68
Aug 29, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$800
Aug 28, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$189.89
Aug 26, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana The Headless Horseman - Whispers in the Well 232/204 (Enchanted) 232/204$260
Aug 16, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$196.75
Aug 14, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow Enchanted 232/204 EN NM 232/204$279.99
Aug 12, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow Enchanted Foil 232/204 232/204$215
Aug 7, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Enchanted The Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 #232$249.99
Aug 4, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Disney Lorcana #9$255
Aug 2, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA 10-WHISPERS IN THE WELLE NCHANTED HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$480
Aug 1, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Disney Lorcana #9$185.50
Jul 31, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$199.93
Jul 27, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Disney Lorcana #9$202.50
Jul 26, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA EN 10-ENCHANTED #232 THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$620
Jul 19, 2026PSA10eBay2025 Disney Lorcana EN The Headless Horseman Enchanted 232/204 PSA 10 GEM MINT #232$574
Jul 19, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Disney Lorcana #9$250
Jul 19, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana The Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Foil 232/204$230
Jul 13, 2026PSA10eBayDisney Lorcana Enchanted HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10 GEM MINT Whispers In The Well #232$560
Jul 11, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Enchanted The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 #232$350
Jul 11, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Disney Lorcana #9$300
Jul 11, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$200
Jul 9, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$250.48
Jul 6, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$252.20
Jul 5, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Enchanted The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 #232$315
Jul 3, 2026PSA9eBayTAG 9 Disney Lorcana Headless Horseman Alt Art 232/204 Foil Enchanted 232/204$305
Jul 2, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$318.05
Jul 1, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow Enchanted ✅$387.12
Jun 29, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$343.34
Jun 28, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow - Lorcana Enchanted Set 10 232/204 232/204$343.20
Jun 26, 2026PSA10eBay2025 Disney Lorcana EN 10 The Headless Horseman Enchanted #232 PSA 10 GEM MINT$1,150
Jun 24, 2026PSA9eBayLorcana Headless Horseman-Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Foil TAG 9 - Enchanted 232/204$358
Jun 23, 2026PSA10eBay2025 Disney Lorcana EN 10 The Headless Horseman Enchanted #232 PSA 10 GEM MINT$1,100
Jun 18, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow - Lorcana Enchanted Set 10 232/204 232/204$265.86
Jun 16, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman Disney Lorcana En 10-Whispers In The Well Enchanted #232$300
Jun 16, 2026RawTCGplayerThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 Near Mint English Enchanted Holo$300
Jun 12, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow 232/204 Enchanted Foil 232/204$185
Jun 11, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow Foil EN 232/204$300
Jun 9, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow - Lorcana Enchanted Set 10 232/204 232/204$280
Jun 5, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman Terror of Sleepy Hollow - Lorcana Enchanted Set 10 232/204 232/204$133.79
Jun 4, 2026PSA10eBayLorcana The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) #232 PSA 10 232/204$635
May 23, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA EN 10-ENCHANTED #232 THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$394
May 22, 2026PSA10eBayThe Headless Horseman Disney Lorcana En 10-Whispers In The Well 232 2025 PSA 10 #232$350
May 7, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) - Lorcana EN 232/204$199.99
May 7, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Headless Horseman-Terror of Sleepy Hollow Foil 232/204 EN 232/204$122.50
May 6, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$500
May 5, 2026PSA9eBayDisney Lorcana - The Headless Horseman - Enchanted - PSA 9 #232$150
Show 11 more
May 4, 2026RaweBayENCHANTED 232/204 Disney Lorcana Card The Headless Horseman Terror Sleepy Hollow 232/204$129.99
Apr 30, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$351
Apr 27, 2026RaweBayDisney Lorcana Whispers Enchanted The Headless Horseman Terror Of Sleepy Hollow$179.99
Apr 25, 2026RaweBayThe Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow Enchanted 232/204 Disney Lorcana 232/204$167.50
Apr 22, 2026PSA10eBayPSA 10 DISNEY LORCANA EN-10 WHISPERS IN THE WELL 232 THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN 232/204$350
Apr 20, 2026RaweBayDISNEY LORCANA THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN TERROR OF SLEEPY HOLLOW ENCHANTED 232/204$125
Apr 6, 2026PSA10eBayPSA 10 - Disney Lorcana - The Headless Horseman Enchanted Holo 232/204 Whispers 232/204$300
Apr 6, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA EN 10-ENCHANTED #232 The Headless Horseman PSA 10 232/204$300
Apr 5, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED #232 HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$300
Apr 4, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED #232 HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$298
Apr 4, 2026PSA10eBay2025 DISNEY LORCANA WHISPERS IN THE WELL ENCHANTED #232 HEADLESS HORSEMAN PSA 10$293

Grading odds

PSA has graded 102 copies. Where they landed:

PSA 108381.4%
PSA 91211.8%
PSA 854.9%
PSA 722.0%

Why the verdict weights the odds

Only 81.4% of copies reach a 10, which is why the top price is the wrong number to plan around. The verdict beside the card weights each grade’s PSA price by these odds: a submission is worth $484.49 on average against $317.55 for the card plus $79.99 at Regular, the cheapest level PSA will insure it at.

1 of the 3 grades priced above had no sales at that grade, so the figure is modelled from the grades that did rather than observed.

Card facts

Card number
232/204
Rarity
Enchanted
Set released
Nov 7, 2025
PSA population, all printings
102
Printings priced
1
From the same setWhispers in the Well261 cards
Complete set value
$6.4k
7 day move
+0.1%
Open set value list →
Other printings
Whispers in the Well125/204$15.52
All 5 The Headless Horseman cards →

More from Whispers in the Well

All 261 cards →
Ariel - Ethereal Voice (Iconic), Whispers in the Well$1,483–Ariel - Ethereal Voice (Iconic)241/204Hades - Looking for a Deal (Iconic), Whispers in the Well$1,067–Hades - Looking for a Deal (Iconic)242/204Spooky Sight (Enchanted), Whispers in the Well$732.91▲3.0%Spooky Sight (Enchanted)237/204Cinderella - Dream Come True (Enchanted), Whispers in the Well$499.24▼-2.8%Cinderella - Dream Come True (Enchanted)236/204Can't Hold It Back Anymore (Enchanted), Whispers in the Well$256.42▲1.4%Can't Hold It Back Anymore (Enchanted)228/204Demona - Scourge of the Wyvern Clan (Enchanted), Whispers in the Well$236.46▼-0.7%Demona - Scourge of the Wyvern Clan (Enchanted)227/204

What moves the price of this card

The The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) on this page is the Holofoil printing from Whispers in the Well, and it trades at $199.99 in near mint condition. The same name is on one other printing: Whispers in the Well 125/204 at $15.52, so read the set, the number and the rarity together before comparing prices.

Graded, it runs PSA 9 $305, CGC/BGS 9.5 $336, PSA 10 $551.30. PSA has graded 102 copies of it. 71 completed sales are on file.

Condition does most of the work below the surface. A copy with soft corners or a print line off centre trades well under the market price shown here, and a copy clean enough to grade trades well above it, which is why the PSA 10 sits at $551.30. Before you value your own copy, look at the corners under a light and check the centring on the back, where most cards give themselves away.